A little OT: 12 bit vs. 16 bit audio

briggins wrote on 9/18/2005, 8:17 AM
The manual for Sony's camcorders describes the audio modes as 12 bit and 16 bit, saying 12 bit is "To record in the 12 bit mode (two stereo sounds)" and 16 bit is "To record in the 16 bit mode (one stereo sound with high quality)". That's fairly useless if you ask me. What's the best mode to use and what's the difference between the two?

Thanks.

Bruce

Comments

Storyman wrote on 9/18/2005, 4:00 PM
From what you've posted I take it that the 12 bit permits two separate feeds, whereas the 16 takes one feed. You might want two feeds if you have someone being interviewed. Both the interviewee and interviwer would be on separate stereo tracks (12 bit). The irony is that most theatrical films are actually shot in monorual and the tracks are splt, then panned to the correct location. Another reason is to create an out-of-phase track. I don't know how you'd do this with this type of equipment, but professionals sometimes will mic the atmosphere and have it out-of-phase with the actors mic. What happens is that the background sounds are eliminated. (One mixer told me how he used this trick when on location and shooting in an old barn that was home to pigeons in the rafters. He mic'ed the pigeons, put them out of phase, and viola' no pigoens on the track.) (A first had experience was while working on a dramatic series. The shot was of a guy that was thrown out of a third story window and landed on some trash cans. Stereo was relatively new to television at the time (80's) and the AP was told to check tracks. He listened to each track separately on a one head moviola and everything seemed okay until airing. What aired was the guy was thrown out of the third story window and silently landed on the trash cans--the FX were out of phase and canceled each other out.) Sorry about the OT stories.
Former user wrote on 9/19/2005, 11:12 AM
16 bit gives you a better quality recording.

The 12 bit mode allows for 2 stereo tracks to be recorded, but most software will only capture the first stereo track. The second track requires some workarounds to capture sometimes.

Stay with 16 bit.

Dave T2
ScottW wrote on 9/19/2005, 11:22 AM
Why useless? With 16 bit audio you still have 2 channels - left and right.

--Scott
briggins wrote on 9/22/2005, 6:57 AM
All,

The reason for my post was not that I thought 16 bit or 12 bit was useless but that the manual's description of the two was useless.

Thanks to the replies, I've got a clearer understanding now of what this setting does and I think I will indeed stick with 16 bit.

Thanks, everyone, for the help.

Bruce